A-B TESTS    
 

 

Headphone Amps

A/B Comparison #1

Beta 22

 

DAC: Cambridge Audio  DAC Magic - via SPDIF
 
Source: Various FLAC Music Files
11/9/2010
 
Test conducted using a switch that connected either amp "A" or amp "B" to the headphones; amps were fed in parallel off the DAC.
I carefully matched the volume levels of the two amps using a 1000 Hz tone & SPL Meter


LCD-2

I was very hard pressed to hear ANY difference between the Beta 22 and the M³ on the LCD-2's. MAYBE a touch better bass control on the Beta 22 but then again maybe not.  I would NOT bet money on me being able to tell these two amps apart in a blind test with the LCD-2.

HD-800

With the somewhat exaggerated highs of the HD800's  I began to hear a subtle difference between the two amps.  The highs on the M³ sounded a tad bit harsh.  Also, the "separateness" of various instruments on a track was better with the Beta22. But these differences were quite subtle.

MY CONCLUSIONS

1. I was surprised that I didn't immediately hear incontrovertible differences between these amps. I was expecting a fairly obvious difference in their sounds.

2. These are both good amps- they both sounded pretty wonderful.


The Beta 22 and M³ amps have things in common-  MOSFET output stages, 3-channel "active ground" design- maybe this is why any differences I may have heard were so subtle.

This makes me want to A / B others amps.  I also urge anyone reading this post who owns more than one headphone amp to build their own A / B box and report on your tests.

I expect I will hear more noticeable differences with other amps - such as Cavilli-Kumisa  vs. Beta 22, and also Beta 22 vs various tube amps in my collection.

Below: my Beta 22. In three-channel form, this amp seems quite sensitive to magnetic field noise- I had hum until I put the power transformer in a steel box, you can see it in a grey steel Hammond enclosure there at the lower left. If I had to do it again, I would build this amp as a 2-chassis design.

 

Here's an M³ amp

 

Note

This was the first A/B comparison I posted, which later evolved into many more comparisons and then into this web site.

 

Copyright © 2011